Estimated read time: 3-4 minutes
- Prosecutors dropped plans to use AI to simulate Joyce Yost's voice.
- They sought a third death sentence for Douglas Lovell, convicted of her murder.
- Lovell's re-sentencing is set for Sept. 2027; Yost's remains are still missing.
FARMINGTON — Prosecutors seeking a third death sentence against the man who killed Joyce Yost to prevent her from testifying in a 1985 rape case are abandoning efforts to use artificial intelligence voice cloning at a 2027 sentencing hearing.
Weber County previously created a clone of Yost's voice by feeding snippets of a police interview recording into an AI tool from ElevenLabs. The AI tool let prosecutors enter text and generate digital audio files that sounded substantially similar to a recording of Yost's actual voice.
Yost had given sworn testimony in a June 12, 1985, preliminary hearing, telling a judge that Douglas Lovell had abducted and raped her the prior April. That case was set for trial in August of 1985, but Yost disappeared 10 days before the scheduled start of the trial. Lovell was eventually convicted of the rape. Years later, in 1993, he admitted to murdering Yost and concealing her body, in the hopes that her disappearance would lead to the rape case being dismissed.
Lovell pleaded guilty to Yost's murder in 1993 and received a death sentence, but nearly two decades later the Utah Supreme Court allowed Lovell to withdraw his plea due to a technical error made by the sentencing judge. That led to Lovell standing trial in 2015, at which time he was convicted by a jury and again sentenced to death.
Lovell appealed and in 2024 the Utah Supreme Court overturned his second death sentence, finding that testimony during the 2015 trial about religious doctrines could have improperly swayed the jury. The high court allowed the murder conviction to stand but ordered Utah 2nd District Court Judge Michael DiReda to hold a new sentencing hearing.
The Weber County Attorney's Office is seeking a third death sentence against Lovell. Yost's preliminary hearing testimony from 1985 is a key element to the prosecution's case. A text transcript of Yost's words is preserved in court records, but no audio recording exists.
In past hearings, prosecutors have used human proxies to read Yost's words from the transcript. However, in 2025, Weber County asked DiReda to approve using an AI clone of Yost's voice to present her testimony at Lovell's upcoming re-sentencing.
Lovell's defense resisted and, on August 10, 2026 — the 41-year anniversary of the date Yost was last seen — brought two expert witnesses to court to argue that the AI voice clone should not be allowed as evidence. After that hearing, ElevenLabs told Weber County it would not grant prosecutors a license to use its software.
Judge DiReda had not yet issued a final ruling on the prosecution's request when Weber County Chief Criminal Deputy Attorney Branden Miles told him Friday that the county has not been able to find another AI voice-cloning provider willing to work with it. As a result, the prosecution is abandoning its effort to have a computer-generated simulation of Yost's voice played for the jury.
Lovell's re-sentencing for Yost's murder is currently scheduled to take place in September 2027. Lovell, now 68, was 27 at the time of Yost's death. He has been imprisoned continuously since January 1986. Yost was 39 when she was last seen. Her remains have never been located. The Joyce Yost case is covered in detail in season 2 of KSL's investigative podcast series, COLD.








