Trump administration asks appeals court to lift order blocking mail-in voting rule

BOSTON — President Donald Trump's administration on Monday ​asked an appeals court to lift a judge's order blocking a new rule that would tighten mail-in voting requirements ahead of the November congressional elections.

The Department of Justice asked the Boston-based ‌1st U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals to put on hold a temporary restraining order that prevented the U.S. Postal Service from enforcing its new ⁠rule.

A lower-court judge issued the order on Thursday ​at the behest of Democratic-led states and voting rights ⁠groups.

The administration asked the appeals court to intervene after Boston-based U.S. District Judge Indira Talwani earlier on Monday ‌declined to pause her restraining ‌order. It will remain in place for 14 days while she considers whether to issue ⁠a longer-term injunction at a hearing set for Thursday.

Talwani, an appointee ⁠of Democratic President Barack Obama, in issuing the restraining order had concluded that the postal service's rule risked disenfranchising voters and was likely unlawful and adopted in violation of the Constitution, which gives states the authority to administer elections.

Justice Department lawyers told the 1st Circuit that Talwani's ruling was "gravely mistaken," and the lawsuit appeared based on an unfounded premise that the postal service intends to seize control of the administration of federal elections.

"The ‌rule's improvements and modernizations of USPS's infrastructure for supporting this particularly sensitive ​category of mail are fully consistent with USPS's statutory and constitutional authority," the Justice Department argued.

Should the 1st Circuit decline to halt Talwani's order, the administration could try to seek the intervention of the 6-3 conservative-majority Supreme Court, which last week lifted an earlier injunction the judge had issued that had blocked the postal service from moving forward with the rule.

The postal service issued the rule to implement an executive order the Republican president signed in March after years of Trump calling for tighter rules on voting by mail and pushing ​the false claim that his 2020 presidential election defeat to Democrat Joe Biden was the result of widespread voter fraud.

Under the ‌rule, states must ‌supply the postal service with ⁠lists of mail ballot recipients, and all outbound and return ballot envelopes must bear unique barcodes.

The postal service, under the rule, may refuse to deliver ballots that do not comply with the new standards or are associated with voters who do not appear on the lists.

All 50 states allow for some form of mail-in voting, with 29 allowing ‌voters to ask to cast ​ballots that way without providing a reason and eight conducting their ‌elections entirely by mail. North ⁠Carolina is set on ​Friday to become the first state to mail out ballots for the November election.

Related topics