- Barry McCann disputes a $500 car deposit refund with an Orem dealership.
- The dealership claims the deposit was nonrefundable without written mechanical issues.
- Utah law requires clear refund policies; McCann plans to file a complaint.
OREM — If you pay a deposit for a car and then choose to walk away, should you get your money back?
A Bountiful man sure thinks so. But when a car dealership decided he wasn't entitled to a refund, he decided it was time to Get Gephardt.
Barry McCann was car shopping for his son, who lives in Phoenix. He found a Honda Pilot with a rebuilt title at a dealership in Orem and asked about holding it.
"'What can we do to hold it for a few days with a refundable deposit?'" McCann said he asked. "And he said, 'Okay, 500 bucks.'"
McCann sent the money through Venmo.
When his son arrived and took the car to be inspected, McCann said they were advised not to buy it.

"And when we asked for the $500 deposit back, they refused," McCann said.
McCann said he protested.
"Refundable was absolutely clear as day," McCann said.
He said the dealership told him it had taken the car off the market for him and missed the chance to sell it to someone else.
"Yeah. Maybe it cost them the sale of the car or if somebody else had come along. But that's the agreement we made," McCann said.
The dealership says it made a different agreement
In an email to KSL, managers at Avanesyan Motors said the salesperson repeatedly explained that the deposit was "nonrefundable unless a mechanic provided written documentation identifying a significant mechanical problem with the vehicle."
The dealership said "No written inspection report or documentation" was provided.
Managers said they offered to apply the deposit toward another car. If there really was an issue with the Honda, they said, "we offered to pay to have the issue corrected."
Check the receipt
When two sides disagree about what was said, investigative reporters usually turn to the paperwork.
McCann's receipt shows the date, the amount and the word "Deposit."

It doesn't say whether the deposit is refundable.
What's missing matters
That missing information could matter.
The Utah Division of Consumer Protection told Get Gephardt that businesses have to refund a deposit "unless the refund policy is clearly and conspicuously disclosed."
"Verbal explanations of refund restrictions likely would not satisfy the requirement," said Melanie Hall, a spokesperson for the division.
McCann's next step is to file a complaint with the Division of Consumer Protection.
Before you hand over a deposit, check the paperwork. Is it refundable? Under what conditions? Get those answers in writing.








